Empty Rectangle

An Empty Rectangle is a two-node same-digit AIC in which the second strong-inference node is a box's Empty Rectangle Intersection (ERI): every candidate for the digit inside the box lies on one row and one column, so the two arms act as a single grouped strong link. In strmckr's link typing the signature is type 0 (bilocal) joined to type 3 (ERI).

What is an Empty Rectangle?

Write the construction as (A=B)-(C=D). The first node is an ordinary bilocal strong link (XOR) for one digit in a row, column, or box. The second node is an ERI: all candidates for the digit inside one box sit in the intersection of a single row and a single column — a cross of two arms, where the corner cell may also hold the digit. One arm of the cross is weakly linked (NAND) to side B of the pair; the other arm is endpoint D. ERI is a grouped strong inference — a disjunction over box candidates — not a forcing-chain deduction, so it cannot be produced by on/off propagation over single candidates.

Walkthrough example

The grid below has its pencil marks filled in. Follow the three hint steps to see how the Empty Rectangle for one digit — a bilocal pair bridged to a box whose candidates form a row-column cross — removes the digit from the far arm's line.

Step 1

Consider the Empty Rectangle for 1 in block 5: every 1 candidate inside the box lies on row 6 or column 6, forming an empty-rectangle cross — an ERI grouped strong-inference node.

Sudoku grid showing step 1 of the Empty Rectangle walkthrough, with the ERI box and its row and column arms highlighted.

Step 2

Write the chain as (G1=G6)-(D6, E6 and F6=F5 and F6). The equals signs are strong links (XOR): G1 and G6 are a bilocal pair for 1 in column 7, and the cross forces 1 into row 6 or column 6 inside block 5. The dash is a weak inference (NAND): G6 sees the row 6 arm D6, E6 and F6, so they cannot both contain 1. If G1 is false, G6 is true, the row 6 arm is empty, and 1 must occupy the column 6 arm F5 and F6. Therefore G1 OR the column 6 arm holds 1, possibly both.

Sudoku grid showing step 2 of the Empty Rectangle walkthrough, with the bilocal pair, the bridge cell and the grouped ERI arms highlighted.

Step 3

This is the Type 1 same-digit elimination: because G1 OR one of F5 and F6 is proved for 1, remove 1 from the cells of column 6 outside the box that see G1.

Sudoku grid after the Empty Rectangle deduction, with the eliminated candidate removed from the far arm's line.

The signature (A=B)-(C=D) with a type-3 ERI link supplies one ordinary bilocal strong link, one grouped strong link over the box's row-column cross, and one weak inference, proving A OR D. That relation justifies removing the digit from a candidate that sees both endpoints. ERI is a grouped strong inference, not a forcing chain — the whole box arm is one logical side. You can play free Sudoku to practise spotting empty rectangles with the current candidate state visible.

How to spot it

For one digit, look for a box whose remaining candidates all lie in one row and one column — the empty rectangle. Then find a bilocal pair for the same digit on the line that continues one arm beyond the box. If the pair's cell on that arm is false, the box must place the digit in the perpendicular arm. The digit can then be removed from the perpendicular line outside the box, in cells that also see the pair's far cell.

The logic

Let the bilocal pair be (A=B) and the ERI node (C=D), where C is the arm the pair's bridge cell sees and D is the other arm. If A is false, B is true; B eliminates every candidate in arm C, so the box forces the digit into arm D. Therefore A OR D is true. Any candidate on the far arm's line outside the box that also sees A can be removed — the Type 1 same-digit elimination with a type-3 ERI link. Larger ERI constructs (Dual ER, Bridged ER, n×ERI) embed the same link in longer chains and are outside this page's scope.